Top employee refuses to accept 'Star Performer' Award after making the company $7 million and getting a 3% raise: 'He wouldn't even get up from his seat to accept the plaque.'

3 months ago 35

Want Your Business Featured Here?

Get instant exposure to our readers

Chat on WhatsApp
  • Man in white dress shirt and brown pants sitting on white wooden bench next to a plaque

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • My best employee refused to accept the 'Employee of the Quarter' award in front of everyone.

    Anyway, last week we had a department-wide meeting, and I was supposed to present the 'Star Performer' award to one of my team members.

  • When I called his name, all he did was shake his head and say, 'No, thank you.' He wouldn't even get up from his seat to accept the plaque.

  • This guy literally brought the company $7 million in new business this year, and in return, all he got was a 3% cost-of- living raise and his name on a dusty plaque for 30 days.

  • Quarters and pennies in a stack on a brown table

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • The director was obviously embarrassed, skipped to the next slide, and carried on as if nothing had happened.

  • A man standing in front of a projector screen

    Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.

  • Honestly, I found the situation hilarious, but my direct manager is losing his mind. He's telling me I have to write him up for 'unprofessional conduct, which could jeopardise his annual bonus.

  • Is it unprofessional to refuse to accept an award during a work meeting? I'd argue that it's unprofessional to spring something on an employee, like the pressure to accept an award in front of their colleagues, without discussing it with them beforehand. He might've wanted to prepare a speech! He might be uncomfortable speaking in front of the entire company! There's a chance he's upset that he's getting an award he can only keep for a month, rather than a raise that isn't merely a cost-of-living adjustment. Whatever the case may be, he at least deserves a heads-up before receiving the award, but his boss doesn't even have the decency to do that.

  • I'm not going to do that. I told my manager he'll have to figure out how to handle it himself because, frankly, I found the whole thing comical.

  • At the end of the day, it's not that big of a deal. It's not as if he yelled at his boss for giving him the award. He was just uncomfortable with receiving it for whatever reason. It might be worth it for his manager to talk with him about why he didn't accept the award, but it's probably best that everyone drop it and move on unless they're willing to face a confrontation. 

  • Has anyone ever seen a situation like this happen before?

  • Latter-Risk-7215 he gave them 7m and they handed him a cheap plaque and a 3 percent raise lol of course he refused it your manager wanting to write him up just proves his point companies really dont get loyalty anymore when its this hard to find decent jobs

  • tnmoi Now your manager is going to write you up for unprofessional conduct or not acquiescing/obey orders.

  • There's no world in which the boss does this, and the employee continues to work hard to make the company millions of dollars. If he has proven that he will only be symbolically rewarded and not tangibly, why would he put his sweat and tears into this company?

  • Captain TenilleTTV Employee of the Quarter gets a plaque for 30 days...

  • He should at least get to take it home and put it on his wall!

  • futureformerjd I don't blame the employee. He should be getting a raise or bonus, not some stupid star performer award. A wise man once said, "Show me the money!" My interpretation is that you guys are on the verge of killing the golden goose and are going to lose this guy.

  • carmachu Just point out to the director that he brought in $7 million in new business and all he got was 3% raise and a plague. What did he expect?

  • OFwant2move Explain to your supervisor that not everyone thrives on that type of attention and it was not done to embarrass him (or her)

  • That's very true. An employee should not be punished for being shy, especially when they bring so much to the table.

  • CallNResponse Of all the misguided attempts I've ever seen where mgmt has worked to "improve morale", the 30 day plaque is ... hmm, honestly not the lamest effort I've seen. But it's very close.

  • Muted-Egg3284 Remember always what a complete dumba your direct manager seems to be...

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article

Read Entire Article
Chatroom