39-year-old demands to live with 25-year-old sister instead of parents, gets upset when she presents her with house rules: 'I told her I would expect her to contribute'

2 months ago 27

Want Your Business Featured Here?

Get instant exposure to our readers

Chat on WhatsApp
  • An upset woman lies on her side on a couch, hugging a cushion

    An upset woman lies on her side on a couch, hugging a cushion

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  • While some would like to think that staying with family is the exception to this logic, there is an argument to be had that it is even more important in this instance. People often feel more comfortable exploiting the generosity of those to whom they are related. Being firm in what is expected under these conditions is the only way to make sure that the individual whose home it is doesn't wind up feeling like a doormat.

    It goes without saying that not everyone is going to accept the ground rules for the place they are staying. They do not want to be restricted in that way.

  • Am I wrong for not allowing my sister to move in with me?

    I 25(F) have a sister 39(F), she and her husband separated back in July. When they separated she went to live with our parents, she has hated living with them for the entirety of it as they have what are in my opinion perfectly reasonable rules.

  • Simple things like clean up after yourself, no guest over night, quiet when they go to bed, etc..

  • She wants to move in with me and I've been firmly against it as we have very different lifestyles and I don't want to rearrange my living space to accommodate her.

  • In this story, a young woman was put in a difficult spot when her recently separated older sister requested to live with her. She had been staying with their parents since the breakdown of her relationship with her husband, but wanted to leave as she didn't like the expectations that they had of her.

    The woman was insistent that living in her house would involve similar rules, such as making a contribution to bills and making sure that she came home by a certain time. Her sister was offended by this and turned against her. The younger sibling wanted to know if she had been too harsh.

  • I have a two bedroom house that was a gift from my grandparents after graduating with my bachelors degree, my sister didn't receive a house as she dropped out of high school her senior year, they did pay for her (small) wedding though.

  • I use the spare room for work/sewing/various craft projects, and I don't want to give up the room as it would make my dining room very cluttered and I'm quite fond of the setup I have.

  • My sister called me last week crying, begging me to let her move in. I told her it wouldn't be any better than our parents because I too would have rules and would expect her to contribute to the light bill and groceries, where our parents charge her noting.

  •  she gets a job and remains employed for the duration of her stay.

  • no guest (which sounds harsh but she has a very poor judge of character and I don't want the kind of people she brings in my house).

  • 10pm curfew as I'm not willing to deal with getting my dogs settled if she wakes them coming in.

  • Cleaning up after herself. And finally not bothering my belongings. I sent her the list, including that I would expect her to pay 25% of the light bill and either buy her own food or contribute the same amount to groceries.

  • She called me and screamed at me, calling me controlling, greedy, telling me I'm a horrible person for wanting her to be homeless (she wouldn't be homeless?) and made numerous facebook post about me.

  • My parents don't believe I've done anything wrong, but with how she's reacted I'm wondering if I'm actually being an ah le here.

  • My goal is to protect my peace and sanity, but it's not worth it if it means i'm being horrible to my sister.

  • An upset woman clutches her head with both hands while sitting on a couch

    An upset woman clutches her head with both hands while sitting on a couch

    The image does not depict the actual subjects of the story. Subjects are models.

  •  actually you don't have to live. by the 10pm rule because if yo

  • Racoon_In_a_Hat Original Poster's Reply Both of my dogs are in their teens and very attached to their night time routine, I'm home by 8pm at the latest to avoid disturbing their routine. It may be my house but I still have to follow the dogs rules

  • Time-Tie-231 So unfair. Why should qualification be rewarded so much and for the sister, practically nothing, by comparison?

  • Racoon_In_a_Hat Original Poster's Reply At one point they offered to pay off her and her husbands home if she got her GED, but she wasn't interested. I'm much younger than my sister though so I'm not sure of the circumstances when she was still in school. Prior to the day of my graduation I was unaware of the house, but their reasoning was they wanted me to have an easy start after the effort I put into my degree.

  • Comeback_321 Good God. Do NOT let her move in even if she agrees to this up front. She showed you who she is and she'll pretend for a month and then you'll be in h I. It's your house. She needs to get herself together!! Also write up a lease so she has no legal claim to sta if you give her notice if you ever decide to proceed with this. everything documented. Notarized. Notaries are free at a bank. Two copies of each agreement. Written notice when she needs to go. NTA. Don't even go there!

  • annorafoyle You're obviously not the AH here and I think it's absurd that you are even asking, tbh.

  • SafeWord9999 Pay attention. She's just shown you how she handles situations BEFORE she even moved in. Her reaction is a blessing cos now you're justified in your NO

  • No-College4662 Stick to your plan, it's a good one. nta

  • JessND2 It's not that you didn't allow it; she had a choice. The rules you set are very reasonable; there have to be rules in a shared living situation. I would only see something wrong with it if she were truly going to become homeless; otherwise, I'm completely in favor

  • LuckySection446 NTA. You're actually nicer than me. I would've thrown it into her face that she needs to get her sh together and do some reflection. She's jobless and living rent free with her parents at 39 years old. She sounds extremely ungrateful. She just separated. She has the ability to turn it all around, but instead sounds like a freeloader (no wonder she and her husband separated). I know this sounds harsh, but she needs to hear the truth.

  • No_Nefariousness4801 NTA. Don't let her gaslight you into doubting yourself. Your expectations are perfectly reasonable, generous even. If she wants to do whatever she wants whenever she wants, she needs to get her own place. You were straight forward and upfront about what you expect. It's your home. At this point, with her reaction? If I were in your shoes, I'd withdraw the offer and switch to a flat "NO". 'No' is a complete sentence. You don't even have to reason, rationalize, or explain to h

  • Agreeable-Aioli-4514 The fact that she screamed at you and called you names when you provided perfectly reasonable requests says it all. DON'T DO IT. It will ruin your life. But if, by some horrific turn of events, she does end up living with you, write up a very clear and very specific. document of expectations and have her sign and date it BEFORE she moves in. I've watched too many Judge Judy episodes to know how it ends when you don't have something in writing. But just don't do it, please.

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article

Read Entire Article
Chatroom